We urge the Cabinet to reconsider his clemency in light of the fact that there was no unanimous decision even at the highest court of the land, and our learned judges were split in their opinion of whether the death penalty was appropriate in his case
Dear distinguished Ministers,
We are writing this letter of appeal for Kho Jabing, whose petition for clemency was rejected on 19 October 2015. We urge the Cabinet to reconsider his clemency in light of the fact that there was no unanimous decision even at the highest court of the land, and our learned judges were split in their opinion of whether the death penalty was appropriate in his case.
We also seek the compassion of the Cabinet for the family of Jabing, who have gone through much suffering since his original sentencing. His father passed away while Jabing’s case was ongoing, and Jabing’s sister Jumai believes that her father’s illness prior to his death was due to Jabing’s incarceration, which came as a great blow for him. His mother, who has been unable to work due to health reasons, has lost both her sources of financial support and has been living on the goodwill of her neighbours and minimal state welfare ever since then.
On top of her ill-health, the thought of losing Jabing, her only son, is too much for his mother to bear. We cannot imagine the effect his death will have on her wellbeing.
We understand the grievousness of his offence but hope that he will be given a second chance and a more meaningful way to atone for his crime.
We hope that our Ministers will be compassionate and consider all factors related, especially the impact of capital punishment on Jabing’s family, and exercise mercy by commuting his death sentence to that of life imprisonment.
Singapore Working Group on the Death Penalty
Last update: 17 June 2015
Kho Jabing, 31, was convicted and sentenced to death under section 300 (c) of the Penal Code.
In the evening of 17 February 2008, Jabing, together with four of his friends, was at Geylang. According to Jabing’s statement, the intention was to go Geylang to commit a robbery, as their previous plan to rob two co-workers was aborted.
When they spotted their victims along Lorong 4, Jabing assaulted the deceased with what was described as either a piece of wood or a tree branch, which he had picked up while approaching the victim. Galing, his co-accused, also assaulted the victim with a metal belt buckle. The victim later succumbed to the severe and multiple injuries inflicted by the piece of wood.
The Court of Appeal affirmed Jabing’s conviction on 24th May 2011. The court held that it was beyond reasonable doubt that Jabing intended to inflict multiple head injuries on the deceased. Jabing was thus sentenced to suffer the mandatory death penalty, which was still in place during his sentence and conviction.
Jabing was afforded an opportunity to be re-sentenced because of the amendments to the death penalty regime in 2013. On 18 November 2013, Justice Tay Yong Kwang re-sentenced Jabing to life imprisonment and 24 strokes of the cane. The prosecutor appealed the re-sentencing decision. On 14th January 2015, the Court of Appeal, by a majority decision (with two out of the five judges dissenting) overturned Justice Tay’s decision and sentenced Jabing to death.
The majority justified imposing the death sentence on the basis that Jabing “exhibited a blatant disregard for human life” due to the “sheer savagery and brutality exhibited by the Respondent (Jabing)” in inflicting the blows to the deceased.
The minority judges however, disagreed with the death sentence imposed by the majority. Justice Woo Bih Li and Justice Lee Seiu Kin reasoned that there was a “reasonable doubt (as to) whether Jabing’s blows were all inflicted when the deceased was laying on the ground” which made it “unsafe to conclude beyond reasonable doubt that he (Jabing) acted in away which exhibited a blatant disregard for human life”.
Jabing has exhausted all legal avenues. He is currently awaiting a reply from the President on his clemency petition, which was submitted in April this year.
- Written judgement from Jabing and Galing’s appeal in 2011
- Written judgement from Jabing’s appeal in 2013
- Written judgement from Court of Appeal decision in 2015
Source : swgdp.wordpress.com
Background : secondchances.asia
President of Singapore
His Excellency Tony Tan Keng Yam Office of the President of the Republic of Singapore
Orchard Road, Singapore 238823
Fax: (65) 67353135
Prime Minister of Singapore
Lee Hsien Loong Prime Minister’s Office
Istana Annexe, Orchard Road, Singapore 238823
Fax: (65) 63328983
Minister of Law and Home Affairs
Mr. K Shanmugam
100 High Street, #08-02 The Treasury, Singapore 179434
Fax: (65) 6332 8842
Deputy Prime Minister & Coordinating Minister for National Security
Deputy Prime Minister & Coordinating Minister for Economic and Social Policies
Coordinating Minister for Infrastructure & Minister for Transport
Minister for Trade and Industry (Trade)
Minister for Manpower
Minister for Communications and Information, Minister-in-charge of Muslim Affairs & Minister-in-charge of Cyber Security
Minister for Defence
Minister for Foreign Affairs
Minister for Health
Minister for Trade and Industry (Industry)
Minister for Finance
Minister for Culture, Community and Youth
Leader of the House
Minister, Prime Minister’s Office
Minister for Social and Family Development
Minister for National Development
Minister for the Environment and Water Resources
Acting Minister for Education (Schools) & Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Transport
Acting Minister for Education (Higher Education and Skills) & Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Defence
Senior Minister of State, Prime Minister’s Office
Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Finance & Ministry of Law
Senior Minister of State, Ministry of the Environment and Water Resources & Ministry of Health
Senior Minister of State, Prime Minister’s Office, Ministry of Foreign Affairs & Ministry of Transport
Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Defence & Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth & Ministry of Finance
Deputy Government Whip
Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Home Affairs & Ministry of National Development Deputy
Leader of the House
Minister of State, Ministry of Manpower
Minister of State, Prime Minister’s Office & Ministry of Manpower
Deputy Government Whip
Minister of State, Ministry of Health
Minister of State, Ministry of Communications and Information & Ministry of Health
Mayor, North West CDC
Mayor, Central Singapore CDC
Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Education & Ministry of Social and Family Development
Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Education & Ministry of Trade and Industry
Mayor, South West CDC
Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth
Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs
Emeritus Senior Minister
MP LOW Thia Khiang
MP Dr Lily NEO
MP Cedric FOO Chee Keng
MP Christopher DE SOUZA
MP Assoc Prof FATIMAH Lateef
MP LEE Yi Shyan
MP LIM Biow Chuan
MP ZAQY Mohamad
MP Er Dr LEE Bee Wah
MP Dr LIM Wee Kiak
MP Ms Jessica TAN Soon Neo
MP Ms Sylvia LIM
MP Dr CHIA Shi-Lu
MP ANG Hin Kee
MP ANG Wei Neng
MP CHEN Show Mao
MP Ms FOO Mee Har
MP GAN Thiam Poh
MP Dr INTAN AZURA Binte Mokhtar
MP Dr JANIL Puthucheary
MP MUHAMAD FAISAL Abdul Manap
MP David ONG Kim Huat
MP ONG Teng Koon
MP PRITAM Singh
MP SITOH Yih Pin
MP TAY Teck Guan Patrick
MP Ms TIN Pei Ling
MP Edwin TONG Chun Fai
MP VIKRAM Nair
MP Alex YAM Ziming
MP ZAINAL Bin Sapari
MP PNG Eng Huat
MP Miss Cheryl CHAN Wei Ling
MP Miss CHENG Li Hui
MP CHONG Kee Hiong
MP Desmond CHOO
MP Dr KOH Poh Koon
MP KWEK Hian Chuan Henry
MP Louis NG Kok Kwang
MP Ms Joan PEREIRA
MP Ms RAHAYU Mahzam
MP SAKTIANDI Supaat
MP Ms SUN Xueling
MP Dr TAN Wu Meng
MP YEE Chia Hsing
MP Melvin YONG Yik Chye
NMP Ms LEE Li Lian
NMP Leon PERERA
NMP Dennis TAN Lip Fong
How to Support The Campaign
This is to inform you of the imminent execution of Kho Jabing, a Malaysian national from Sarawark.
It is currently scheduled for GMT/UTC 22:00, Thursday, 5 Nov 2015 (6:00am, Friday, 6 Nov, Singapore time)
You may also have received information on this case from our other partners here.
He has exhausted all normal appeals through the courts and his clemency application was rejected on the 19th of October.
This is a recent petition focusing the unique problem of Jabing’s case within the criminal justice system in Singapore.
We would like to request the members of your organisations and that your networks to consider writing an appeal to the members of the Cabinet and the Parliament whose addresses have been copied at the bottom.
Soe Min Than
Towards A Vibrant Civil Society